Over three years, sustainability theme funds trailed the world index by more than ordinary equity funds

Counting only the active funds in developed markets, the gap to the index over three years was just over 4 points, smaller than in each of the five sustainability theme groups.
| Group | Funds | Index funds | Fee | Cost | Return | Vs index | Range | Upper / lower quartile | Vol / Sharpe |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
WorldIndex Xtrackers MSCI World UCITS ETF (1C) | — | — | — | +16.4 % | — | — | — | — | |
14 of 17 with return data | 17 | None | 1.40 % no index funds | — — | +12.9 % | -3.5 pp | +0.2 → +40.5 40.4 pp | +31.6 / +3.2 28.4 pp | 16.9 % / 0.54 n = 11 / 9 |
12 of 15 with return data | 15 | None | 1.38 % no index funds | — — | +10.1 % | -6.3 pp | +5.7 → +17.1 11.4 pp | +14.6 / +5.9 8.7 pp | 13.3 % / 0.50 n = 9 / 6 |
22 of 28 with return data | 28 | 1 | 1.25 % Index 0.10 % | — — | +10.0 % | -6.4 pp | +1.9 → +16.0 14.1 pp | +14.6 / +5.1 9.5 pp | 14.5 % / 0.51 n = 19 / 16 |
12 of 15 with return data | 15 | None | 1.00 % no index funds | — — | +7.1 % | -9.3 pp | -0.3 → +28.6 28.9 pp | +16.0 / +1.0 15.0 pp | 22.3 % / -0.18 n = 8 / 8 |
| 5 | None | 1.50 % no index funds | — — | +4.4 % | -11.9 pp | +1.5 → +6.4 5.0 pp | +6.4 / +2.3 one fund per band | 14.9 % / 0.15 n = 4 / 4 | |
| 4 | None | 1.50 % no index funds | — — | +0.5 % | -15.9 pp | -2.3 → +4.5 6.8 pp | +4.5 / -2.3 one fund per band | 7.5 % / -0.21 n = 3 / 3 | |
Aksjefond, utviklede markederBenchmark 92 of 150 with return data | 150 | 22 | 1.35 % Index 0.20 % | — — | +12.8 % | -3.5 pp | -1.6 → +24.3 25.8 pp | +18.9 / +4.9 14.0 pp | 12.8 % / 0.98 n = 72 / 53 |
Over five years the theme groups trailed by about 7 to 12 points, ordinary equity funds by about 4.
| Group | Funds | Index funds | Fee | Cost | Return | Vs index | Range | Upper / lower quartile | Vol / Sharpe |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
WorldIndex Xtrackers MSCI World UCITS ETF (1C) | — | — | — | +14.4 % | — | — | — | — | |
17 of 28 with return data | 28 | 1 | 1.25 % Index 0.10 % | — — | +7.7 % | -6.7 pp | +1.9 → +12.8 10.9 pp | +12.3 / +3.4 8.9 pp | 14.5 % / 0.51 n = 19 / 16 |
13 of 17 with return data | 17 | None | 1.40 % no index funds | — — | +7.6 % | -6.8 pp | +1.3 → +22.2 20.9 pp | +16.3 / +2.2 14.1 pp | 16.9 % / 0.54 n = 11 / 9 |
10 of 15 with return data | 15 | None | 1.38 % no index funds | — — | +7.4 % | -7.0 pp | +1.6 → +16.0 14.4 pp | +13.6 / +3.0 10.6 pp | 13.3 % / 0.50 n = 9 / 6 |
| 5 | None | 1.50 % no index funds | — — | +4.5 % | -9.9 pp | +1.5 → +6.6 5.1 pp | +6.6 / +2.2 one fund per band | 14.9 % / 0.15 n = 4 / 4 | |
11 of 15 with return data | 15 | None | 1.00 % no index funds | — — | +2.5 % | -11.9 pp | -11.4 → +20.2 31.6 pp | +14.1 / -4.9 19.0 pp | 22.3 % / -0.18 n = 8 / 8 |
| 4 | None | 1.50 % no index funds | — — | +2.2 % | -12.2 pp | +0.3 → +3.9 3.7 pp | +3.9 / +0.3 one fund per band | 7.5 % / -0.21 n = 3 / 3 | |
Aksjefond, utviklede markederBenchmark 80 of 150 with return data | 150 | 22 | 1.35 % Index 0.20 % | — — | +10.2 % | -4.2 pp | -2.6 → +18.4 21.0 pp | +15.0 / +3.5 11.5 pp | 12.8 % / 0.98 n = 72 / 53 |
Over ten years the largest group, Climate and ecology, is roughly level with ordinary equity funds, both just over 3 points behind the index. That figure rests on nine funds.
Almost none beat the index
Of just over 50 active theme funds with a three-year record, only a couple beat MSCI World. Among the active funds in developed markets, about one in four did. Over five years a couple of just over 40 active theme funds beat the index, against around one in seven of the active funds in developed markets.
The average of the best quarter of funds was below the index in all five theme groups over three and five years; in Water and Food security that quarter is a single fund. Among ordinary equity funds and in Megatrends, a theme with no sustainability profile, the best quarter was above the index. Over five years, though, Megatrends trailed the index by about as much as Climate and ecology.
Not a question of price
The median fee is between 1.00 and 1.50 per cent in the five groups, against 1.35 for active funds in developed markets. Differences of a few tenths cannot explain a gap of several percentage points a year, and Energy transition, with the lowest median, was among the groups furthest behind over five years. The managers have not been asked about the reason for the gap.
Method: The group average is an equal-weighted average of the returns of the funds in FundTelligence's peer groups that have figures for the whole period, in Norwegian kroner, after the funds' costs and annualised. The periods run to the beginning of October 2026: three years from October 2023, five years from October 2021. The quartile figure is the average of the funds in the quartile. MSCI World is measured with the Xtrackers MSCI World UCITS ETF in kroner. "Ordinary equity funds" is the peer group for developed-market equity funds, about 150 funds including 22 index funds; the five theme groups hold 67 funds, one of them an index fund. The average for active funds alone and the count of funds that beat the index cover active funds with returns for the whole period. They and the ten-year figures are not shown in the tables. Only funds that still exist are included. The theme groups are FundTelligence's groups by theme, not an ethical or regulatory classification. Figures retrieved 8 October 2026. The article describes historical returns and is not a recommendation.