Skip to main content
Back to articles
Commentary Published 18 July 2026· Updated 12 October 2026

Pure energy funds have trailed broad climate funds by a wide margin over five years

En rekke med 20 små punkter der to vokser til store gylne bobler – fornybarsektoren blåste seg opp og sprakk to ganger på tjue år.
Measured in Norwegian kroner. Developed-market equity funds returned around 10 per cent a year on average, more than both theme groups.

Over five years, the funds FundTelligence classifies as energy transition have on average returned about five percentage points a year less than the climate-and-ecology funds. The energy funds' average is held up by one fund, Polar Capital Smart Energy, the group's best.

Peer groups side by side
Energy-transition funds, climate-and-ecology funds and developed-market equity funds: annual return over five years in NOK, average and quartiles
Captured 12 Oct 2026
Energiomstilling
15 funds · no index funds · Fee 1.00 %
+2.5 %
Klima og økologi
28 funds · 1 index funds · Fee 1.25 %
+7.7 %
Aksjefond, utviklede markeder
150 funds · 22 index funds · Fee 1.35 %
+10.2 %
1 of 2 groups hold no index funds. Returns beyond one year are annualised.

Different contents in the portfolios

Both have «miljø» (environment) in the name, but DNB Miljøinvest is classified as an energy-transition fund and Nordea Klima og Miljø as a climate fund.

Five routes through the energy transition
Three energy-transition funds (the first three) and three climate-and-ecology funds, including the climate fund with the highest share: share of the portfolio in energy-transition companies, latest holdings report (June–September 2026)
Captured 12 Oct 2026

Renewable Energy Supply Chain

Grid & Energy Infrastructure

Energy Production

Energy Efficiency

Transport Electrification & Efficiency

Largest holdings in selected cell: Storebrand Fornybar Energi · Grid & Energy Infrastructure

33.5%

The list shows only the largest classified holdings in the cell.

No double counting: Each tagged holding follows one theme path. Percentages are shares of the whole fund. A missing cell means the tags provide no positive evidence for the category — not necessarily that exposure is zero.

All the energy funds with complete holdings data have more than three quarters of the portfolio in energy-transition companies, as expected for funds with such a theme. Among the climate funds with complete data, half have around a quarter, and the highest has about half.

One fund pulls up, one pulls down

Apart from Polar Capital Smart Energy, the energy funds range from an annual loss of around 12 per cent in BNP Clean Energy Solutions to just under 8 per cent, and most have returned less than 5.

Peer groups side by side
The same groups over three years, annual return in NOK
Captured 12 Oct 2026
Energiomstilling
15 funds · no index funds · Fee 1.00 %
+7.1 %
Klima og økologi
28 funds · 1 index funds · Fee 1.25 %
+10.0 %
Aksjefond, utviklede markeder
150 funds · 22 index funds · Fee 1.35 %
+12.8 %
1 of 2 groups hold no index funds. Returns beyond one year are annualised.

Over three years the gap between the averages is about three percentage points, and both groups are still below the developed-market equity funds.

Peer groups side by side
The same groups over ten years, annual return in NOK
Captured 12 Oct 2026
Energiomstilling
15 funds · no index funds · Fee 1.00 %
+7.2 %
Klima og økologi
28 funds · 1 index funds · Fee 1.25 %
+11.6 %
Aksjefond, utviklede markeder
150 funds · 22 index funds · Fee 1.35 %
+11.8 %
1 of 2 groups hold no index funds. A quartile resting on one fund is one fund, not a quartile. Returns beyond one year are annualised.

Over ten years, with far fewer funds, the average is lower for the energy funds, but the medians are almost equal.

Funds that have been closed are not included, and in a group with large falls that probably lifts the energy average the most. The funds also own many of the same shares, so they are not independent measurements.

The managers have not been asked why the funds have performed as they have.

Method: The groups are FundTelligence's peer groups «Theme – Energy Transition» (15 funds), «Theme – Climate & Ecology» (28 funds) and «Developed Markets (DM) – Equities» (about 150 funds). Energy Transition was split out of the climate group on 25 July 2026, towards the end of the period, and the classification is applied backwards over the whole period. The return is the average of the funds' annual returns in NOK, one share class per fund, and only funds with a return for the whole period are included; the counts are in the tables. The quartile average is the average of the funds in the weakest quarter. Polar Capital Smart Energy reached a five-year history at the end of September 2026 and is included in the five-year figures from then. The ten-year medians are calculated by us from the fund figures retrieved on 8 October 2026 (over ten years all funds in the sample are active); the tables are updated and may show different figures. Holdings are from the funds' latest report (June–September 2026) and are shown only for funds with complete holdings data; they show what the funds own now, not through the period.

Share this article