Skip to main content
Back to articles
Commentary Published 21 July 2026· Updated 9 October 2026

Over five years, active funds beat index funds more often in Norway than the US

Abstrakt rutenett av gullfargede søyler i ulik lengde mot mørk bakgrunn – et bilde på hvor ulikt aktive fond har truffet mot indeksfondene på tvers av markeder.
About half of the active Norway funds did better than the average of the index funds in their own market over five years. In the US it was around one in ten, with a fee gap that is only slightly larger.

Over five years, the share of active equity funds that beat the average of the index funds in their own market ranges from under one in ten to about half across seven market groups.

How often do active funds beat the index-fund average?
Share of active funds that beat the average of the index funds in their own comparison group, in NOK, sorted by five years
Captured 9 Oct 2026
MarketYear to date1 year3 years5 years10 yearsFee gap
Norge
3/39
8 %
8/39
21 %
16/32
50 %
16/31
52 %
14/26
54 %
1.01 pp
Globalt
24/80
30 %
29/83
35 %
16/72
22 %
25/62
40 %
7/42
17 %
1.15 pp
Norden
7/23
30 %
7/23
30 %
12/22
55 %
8/20
40 %
—1.17 pp
Vekstmarkeder
39/67
58 %
43/67
64 %
29/65
45 %
25/63
40 %
17/47
36 %
1.22 pp
Europa
21/72
29 %
22/71
31 %
24/68
35 %
22/67
33 %
13/55
24 %
1.30 pp
USA
15/49
31 %
16/50
32 %
11/49
22 %
4/46
9 %
8/37
22 %
1.30 pp
Global All-Country Equities
11/56
20 %
14/56
25 %
5/55
9 %
4/51
8 %
3/40
8 %
1.20 pp
Sektor – teknologi
8/26
31 %
9/26
35 %
10/26
39 %
——1.24 pp
Periods resting on fewer than 3 index funds are omitted · Difference in median management fee between active funds and index funds

The difference in median ongoing charges between active funds and index funds lies between 1.0 and 1.3 percentage points in every group.

Norway has both the smallest gap and the highest share. Funds investing in both developed and emerging markets («All markets (DM+EM)» in the table) have a gap in the middle of the field, 1.2 percentage points, but the lowest share, below the US, where the gap is 1.3.

In these seven groups the fee gap does not follow the same pattern as the shares. Fees are the median for the cheapest share class, and investors may own more expensive classes.

Over three years, too, the US and All markets sit low. About one in five active US funds beat the average, and fewer in the other group.

The caveats

Active funds that have been closed or merged are missing from the figures, which lifts every share. The bias need not be equally large everywhere. In Norway there are about a fifth fewer active funds with a five-year history than with a one-year history, and among global funds about a quarter. In the US and All markets it is around a tenth. The figures do not separate closed funds from funds launched along the way. If part of the difference is closures, some of the gap between markets may come from which funds survived.

The basis of comparison is thin, too. Each group is measured against its own average of 6–11 index funds, and one index fund with unusual fees or a large deviation from its index can move a group's share.

The figures are not adjusted for risk. A fund may have beaten the average by taking more risk than the index funds.

Over three years and shorter, Norway is not at the top. Over one year, around one in four active Norway funds beat the average, among the lowest shares in the table. The figures also move between updates: in a single day in October, two fewer Norway funds were above the average over five years, and the share went from just over to just under half.

Neither the fund managers nor other sources have been asked why the markets differ.

Method: The source is FundTelligence's comparison of active funds and index funds per comparison group. The figures were retrieved on 8 October 2026. An active fund counts as having beaten the index funds when its return over the period is higher than the average return after costs of the index funds in the same comparison group. The comparison is not with an index. The share is the number of such funds divided by the number of active funds with a return for the period. The fee gap is the difference between the median ongoing charge for active funds and for index funds, measured on the cheapest share class; the number of funds in the fee figures may differ from the number in the return figures. The article describes the market; it is not a recommendation.

Share this article