ModuleStandalone Writeups
10 min read

Writeup: Active vs Index

10 min read

Writeup: Active vs Index - When Can Active Pay Off?

This is general educational content, not investment advice. Examples and rules of thumb are illustrative and may change; consider your own situation.

This writeup focuses on one question: does expected alpha survive the cost gap versus index alternatives?

Core idea

A simple expectation model: expected net excess return ≈ (hit rate x gross alpha) - cost difference

This is not a final answer, but a disciplined starting point.

Interactive simulator

Active vs Index Scenario Lab

Stress test whether expected alpha survives fees and tracking-error risk.

Fee difference
1.00%
Expected net excess
-0.10%
Expected info ratio
-0.02
Indication
Index likely favored

How to use this in practice

  1. Input realistic gross alpha and hit rate.
  2. Input the actual cost gap versus index options.
  3. Use tracking error as a risk proxy for how demanding the active mandate is.

Compare Funds Side by Side (preview signed out, simple with an account, full with Plus)

Connect to lessons

Sources and relevance

  • Source date check target: re-verify at each scheduled review date.
  • Jurisdiction fit: global evaluation logic; implementation should be adapted to Norwegian account/tax context.

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion.